John C. Bunnell

Noted & Booked

The books mentioned in this space reflect both recent and rediscovered reading; some will be new and some not.  Links will generally direct you to the Powell's Books Web site, or sometimes directly to a book's publisher (mostly in the case of smaller or more specialized presses).

Kaleidoscope (Dorothy Gilman) Command Decision (Elizabeth Moon)
Working for the Devil (Lilith Saintcrow) Epiphany (Sherman & Shwartz) 
Kaleidoscope • Dorothy Gilman

Though best known for her "Mrs. Pollifax" mysteries, Dorothy Gilman has written a number of other books, and I am especially fond of this one.  A free-standing sequel to The Clairvoyant Countess, this is a mystery tale -- or perhaps a cluster of linked tales -- featuring the psychically gifted Madame Karitska as she solves a number of puzzles with the aid of Lt. Pruden of the Trafton police.

Gilman's mysteries are old-fashioned in the best sense; while they fit firmly into what's now called the "cozy" subgenre, they do not shy away from evil or its effects; on the contrary, they examine it frankly and thoughtfully through our protagonists' eyes.  And although it's introduced almost entirely via offstage allusion, there's a nominal SF element here, also intriguingly explored. 

Command Decision • Elizabeth Moon 

Space opera isn't exactly thin on the ground these days -- but space opera that combines first-rate high adventure with thoughtful characterization and well-developed political & economic intrigue is decidedly uncommon.  And that's what Command Decision delivers; fourth in Moon's "Vatta's War" sequence, it raises the stakes on all sides of its multi-faceted plot, adding dimension to its various protagonists as it unfolds.

Moon's military background shows in her intricately planned space engagements.  More of a surprise -- and a welcome one -- is the multi-faceted wit that permeates this installment, by turns sardonic, impish, and wickedly barbed.  David Weber may be more popular nowadays . . . but Elizabeth Moon is writing better books.

Working for the Devil • Lilith Saintcrow 

If Laurell K. Hamilton's books are the dark-fantasy equivalent of hot (read "erotic") romance, Lilith Saintcrow's Dante Valentine saga is paranormal suspense with a liberal dash of film noir.  Dante -- more often called Danny -- is a Necromance, capable of invoking and conversing with the recently dead.  Hers is a rare talent even in a future world where magic is an everyday fact of life and Lucifer wields power on Earth and in Hell alike.

But what the Devil needs from Danny isn't her spiritual ability.  He needs her to track and kill a demon who's escaped from Hell with a dangerously powerful artifact.  She is both uniquely qualified for the job (neither man nor demon, we're told, can kill the elusive Santino), and uniquely motivated (among the many humans Santino's killed was a close friend of hers).  And the promised pay isn't bad, either....

There's an ocean of paranormal adventure available these days; Saintcrow's work rises above much of it by virtue of its brisk plotting and well-developed background milieu.  Story is what counts here, and Saintcrow has a powerful story to tell.

Vulcan's Soul #3: Epiphany
    Josepha Sherman & Susan Shwartz 

Fair warning: the Vulcan's Soul trilogy is more properly a single extended epic, rather than a trio of linked novels.  And it's an ambitious epic at that, a story designed to integrate and draw together several somewhat divergent strands of Star Trek mythology -- specifically, the varying visions of Romulan culture shown in the Next Generation TV series, in Diane Duane's extraordinary "Rihannsu" novels (most particularly The Romulan Way, written with Peter Morwood), and the film Star Trek: Nemesis, which introduced the sharply mutated Reman sub-race.

Sherman and Shwartz, though, are up to the challenge, and Epiphany wraps up the saga in impressive fashion.  Like The Romulan Way, this is in large part a historical tale; where Duane and Morwood recount the Sundering largely from the Vulcan perspective, the present tale chronicles the journey only hinted at in the earlier book -- drawing skillfully not only on Duane's work, but on strands from a host of other literary and filmed Star Trek lore.  To a degree, the historical narrative overshadows parts of the "present-day" plot, involving the newly encountered Watraii, a long-lost artifact, and (as usual) the threat of interstellar war.

But the authors are as effective at portraying familiar characters -- Spock, Picard, Saavik, and more than one memorable Romulan Commander -- as they are at expanding the milieu's historical dimensions, and the conclusion of this saga sets events in motion that bid fair to dramatically alter the shape of the Star Trek universe.  Those who insist that "tie-in" novels can't have solid literary or storytelling values clearly haven't been reading Trek fiction lately.  The Vulcan's Soul saga is first-rate Trek, but it's also solid straight-ahead science fiction.